
During childhood visits to my armchair detective grandmother’s home in East Northport, Long Island, in the late 1960s and early 1970s, I listened intently when she offered theories for such high profile cases as the Lindbergh kidnapping and the Alice Crimmins case. She often mentioned an unsolved taxi driver murder that occurred in Northport in 1955; for me, it sparked a lifelong fascination. I grew up to become a Suffolk County Police Officer. After twenty-one years on the job, and having survived breast cancer, I recently retired to spend more time with my family and work on a book about the very case my grandmother inspired me to pursue.
So, it wasn’t unusual for me, at such a young age, to begin following a crime that received nationwide attention in February 1970: the murder of 26-year-old pregnant Colette MacDonald and her two young daughters. Although the brutal crime -- which had echoes of the Manson-family killings just six months earlier -- occurred at a military base at Fort Bragg in Fayetteville, North Carolina, there was a local angle: Colette and her husband, U.S. Army Captain and surgeon Jeffrey MacDonald, were high school sweethearts from Patchogue, Long Island, and Colette’s parents lived in Suffolk County at the time of the murder; this meant the local papers closely monitored the case -- and so did I.
Years later, due to the persistent efforts of Colette’s stepfather, Freddy Kassab (once a staunch supporter of his son-in-law, until he gained access to documents and discovered inconsistencies), Jeffrey MacDonald was brought to trial for murdering his own family.
MacDonald, who maintained that a group of drug-crazed “hippies” were responsible for slaughtering his family and stabbing him with an ice pick, had hoped that working closely with journalist/author Joe McGinniss would result in his innocence being revealed to prosecutors. MacDonald allowed McGinniss full access to his legal team.
MacDonald was convicted of murder and received three life sentences.
I bought Fatal Vision when it was released in 1983; I was eager to read the story-behind-the story of the case I had followed for so long. The book was quite an experience, one that has stayed with me all these years later. I remember being led down a garden path, thinking MacDonald might be innocent, as McGinniss must have first believed; but as I continued reading, McGinniss revealed how he became convinced of the former Green Beret doctor’s guilt -- which convinced me, too. The physical evidence was overwhelming, and the insight provided by the author about a man convicted of killing his family was absolutely chilling.
In November 1984, a two-part adaptation of Fatal Vision aired on television (see a clip on YouTube describing the pajama top evidence here). Karl Malden's portrayal of Freddy Kassab was brilliant.
Jeffrey MacDonald brought a lawsuit against Joe McGinniss for fraud and breach of contract, which was settled out of court, reportedly for $325,000, after a mistrial. McGinniss had stayed in MacDonald’s good graces while writing the book, even after he made the realization that MacDonald was guilty -- he just withheld that detail as he continued to pursue the story.
Janet Malcolm’s book, The Journalist and the Murderer, expanded on her essays that first appeared in the New Yorker in 1989 that explored journalistic ethics as a result of the lawsuit Jeffrey MacDonald brought against Joe McGinniss.
In 1995, a book written by Jerry Allen Potter and Fred Bost, Fatal Justice: Reinvestigating the MacDonald Murders, presents an opposing argument to Fatal Vision.
Fatal Vision remains one of my favorite true-crime books; I think it's time to revisit this “forgotten” book.
For links to other Forgotten Books, visit Patti Abbott’s blog.
[P.S. If you haven't gotten around to leaving a comment about your experience with raffles, you have until noon on Saturday, June 6th, to be in the running to receive a free copy of the MWA anthology, THE PROSECUTION RESTS, edited by Linda Fairstein. Click here. You may be one of five lucky winners. Good luck!]