
See postscript for loose image relevance. This gentleman and his harvest also reminded me of an apt Chinese proverb: That the birds of worry fly about your head you cannot help. That they make nests in your hair, this you can prevent.
- and I'm better at digesting them than I used to be. When my first MS title was appropriated by someone else under less-than-sunlit circumstances, I fumed. I well understand that titles aren't protected, but after finding a snappy word that captured the essence of my story, checking various places online to make sure it hadn't been used (recently), it was disheartening to be back to nothing on the title page before 'by'. And the interloper was a debut author whose agent coincidentally ( I must assume) had my MS which she'd requested in its entirety and had been sitting on without communicating yay-or-nay nor even responding to my few courteous follow-ups for over 6 months. Black Hole of Calcutta meet Salt in the Wound.
Of course, even once you've found a monikker you love, your agent or editor might despise it. Coincidences of awful duplicate timing do occur, but- demmit!- that's not the point, because I'm talking about the special self-pity of feeling ripped off by people who don't know I'm alive!
And it's happened again. Two days ago, a close (and brave) pal sent me an e-mail with a link to a new, bona fide entertainment entity using the same name as my latest, almost-done project. Sure, if I'd had already had my work sold and circulating, no one would've had the opportunity to use MY TITLE for their current project, and that's my fault. My artist-partner and I are tantalizingly close to having a portfolio package to share in the next month or two, but that's not even also-ran status really. As it turns out, the latest copycat is another SF/F concept, like what I'm developing. It's a different-enough premise, but it's already a fully-fledged interactive online animated series which has posted 23 of 130 splashy episodes to-come. It's no puny, stale graphic novel, oh no. Apparently today, that fixed-frame jive is the province of only osteoporotic Luddites like me. But truthfully, I'd already been concerned after noticing that fantasy juggernaut Neil Gaiman has an emerging film project from his previous book that's got a close name, too. Anyway, I was happy around a year ago when I found the name basically wide-open for use. Having failed to capitalize on it, those syllables are off to dance with better prospects who have cooler duds and their own cars.
Practically, my losses include the use of a related domain that I reserved, but thankfully, hadn't built yet. The online placeholder was cheap, but I'm grateful for more than just that. The premise is still good. The characters and storylines are still good. The artwork's still good. All the fundamentals are there, and this creative gig is about execution as well as luck. But only one of those aspects do I control. So, unlike the lousy rock bands who spend their hazy hours arguing over names and T-shirt logos rather than practicing, I just have to keep producing, let the ideas start percolating again and see what new identity pops up.
Also, due to our casual discussion here of daily word quotas in WOM's comments, I have made a personal pledge and have been faithfully tallying. Therefore, I'm 3000-ish words along in a new story draft for this now-anonymous concept, much further than if I hadn't been inspired and encouraged by you, my pace being a Graham Greene-y saunter without the high quality, of course. So, what I most appreciate in this situation is that I have much more to offer a publisher than just a title. I've only really lost one word. I'm a writer. I ought to have surplus.
P.S. However sanguine I thought I was feeling, to my surprise, subterranean angst burbles. The evidence came during my therapeutic pie-baking as I failed to dust the apple slices with nutmeg and used red pepper instead.
Thursday, September 20, 2007
These things happen -
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

14 comments:
I had a dopey working title for a long time with my current WIP but then, in a moment of inspiration, came up with a snappy one. But I
think the title was a result of the effort on the book.
I also then went out and reserved it as a domain name so others couldn't snap it up, at least on the web.
Maybe you ought to consider making your next title a "something.com" domain name. If you get the book sold, this bit of work will be done already, by the way.
The title thing I totally understand. But RED PEPPER instead of nutmeg? That's a truly awful level of angst!
Alex- thanks for the comments and help. So far, I have purely dopey new titles in mind. I agree that sometimes the best titles come after the full work has taken shape. My second MS was like that. This new thing isn't very IT-centric (more urban fantasy than scifi), so I think a ".com" title might promise something I'm not delivering. Of course, there's still the delay between writing and actual publishing (can be up to 2 years with a major house) when wacky things can happen that sour a name. I do hope that your domain registration intimidates any poachers on your titled turf.
I actually had reserved a related domain name about a year ago to post our conceptual portfolio once it was complete. And at that time, the simple name .com was being placeheld (still is) by what looked like a buy-and-hold website ad referral company, not an entity actually using the name for its own unique content.
However, the SciFi channel series did an end-run around that holder by using the .tv domain. The days of demanding big $ of corporations for domains seems to be over. With everyone using search sites and bookmarks, it's not that hard for a site to be found, even if the web address isn't perfectly plain or logical. Then, as the placeholders drop their registrations, I'm seeing the companies gradually scooping the competing domains back up, over time and for reasonable rates.
There are now so many domain extensions like .info,.tv,.biz, unless someone wants (and can afford) to reserve all of them and their alternate spellings, extended phrases, or plays on the wording, I think the best protection against getting stomped over by someone else is doing real business, whether mercantile or promotional, under that name. It's still no guarantee that someone won't beat you to it or compete against you, but it does scare away well-intentioned schmucks like me who troll the web with my lists of titles looking for previous/conflicting usages. If I'd found this series a year ago- and it wasn't up until a month ago- I'd never have chosen the title.
And now, I get to enjoy that fun all over again. You've got me intrigued about your title though. Sure you don't want to lend it out? :)
Laura- the bottles look the same from their backsides, and I wasn't exactly in surgical lighting. It was a tre intime baking scene. However, I was sparing enough that the pie is quite edible, delicious even. I didn't even tell my husband who's loving it, though his chronically lousy sinuses may leave his palate less than it should be. IMO, it does have the vaguest hint of those red-hot candies, but with the scoops of ice cream, it's actually really nice. I don't know that I'll go so far as to make it my secret ingredient, but I was glad not to have wasted the yummy apples and crust.
Totally get the frustration over the title. I'm convinced something better will come along. BTW, cayenne pepper is my secret baking ingredient.
The title...what a collosal drag! (Love your "I've only really lost one word. I'm a writer. I ought to have surplus.") But oh my! Use the pie-baking scene in your next novel, it's priceless.
Leah- Do tell, what other goodies do you sneak it in, you sly baker?
Lois- I like the phrase Colossal Drag- maybe that's my new title. I've seen or read the salt/sugar baking swap so many times, and I didn't think it happened nearly as easily or often in real life as on sitcoms. I was pleased to have come up with my own authentic revision of the gag with a little more heat and bite.
What's in a name indeed. My debut novel comes out next February and six weeks ago I woke up to learn it's got almost the same title as a new ABC series. So plastered all over Manhattan are bus ads and billboards for something that is not mine, but is so heartbreakingly close it's killing me. Either it will be a big hit and people will think I stole it, or it will tank and I will be connected with a flop. What can you do? (like the blog..I've been lurking.)
Clare2e - I wouldn't give away all my secrets, of course, but I've yet to go wrong with a good glug of rum.
Leah- There isn't much that goes amiss with a good glug.
Rosemary- So nice to meet you across the electrons. Did I mention you look fabulous in pixels? But about the title of your book- Crap! and Ouch!
I've seen the promos for the series you mean, but it looked [hand teetertottering] meh to me. Perhaps due to an overload of this kind of thematic material, if viewers are feeling their paranormal thresholds transgressed like our Laura is? I actually write an urban ghost story and I don't want to see any more of this shlamozzle. On the upside (?),you know how faithless networks are. That namegrabber might be piloted and cancelled before it's even rolling, leaving only a residual "I think I've heard of that. It must be Something Significant" without the wonky aftertaste of a real stinkeroo. Fingers crossed.
BTW, What do I do with a pair of sedges which have flourished so massively, like exploding spores with tufty ornamentia, that they now threaten to block out the sun? A chainsaw buzzcut seems cruel, but how can they be pruned? Or can they?
Oh,never mind. It's declasse of me to try to exploit your expertise at a moment of discouragement and woe.
Unless you're busting with link referrals and advice as your own therapeutic way through the woe. And if helping me can help you, well then....
Leah, we need to know more about the cayenne in baking. I am such a boring cook that I don't even put any kind of pepper in recipes that call for it. So tell me, what am I missing?
Oh, I wandered off topic, sort of, but then I didn't exactly.
Hmmm- titles. I have in some cases agonized and in some cases I just knew what the title was going to be from the start. I have never gone through the "they've stolen my title!!" angst. I can only imagine that it's horrible.
Oh, and I went to Rosemary's site and linked to the "find out what flower you are" thingy and I'm a snapdragon--so don't steal my title or I'll snap your head off.
Now there's a solution!
Terrie
Apologies if this comes through twice..didn't seem to work the first time. Who knows on that series thing...we'll see. You're right tho, it may have come and gone by Feb!
On the sedges, I'd divide them. You can use a saw if they're really tough or two pitchforks pushed/pulled in opposite directions. I think ornamental grasses look good in pots; you might want to try a few in containers elsewhere in your garden. One last thing off-topic..ever had cayenne pepper on sliced fruit? They sell it on the street thay way in Mexico. Yum. Hi, Laura. (We've met at a few MWA things.)
Thanks, Rosemary. I believe my neighbor may be interested in taking halves of such vigorous specimens.
Also, you reminded me of the ears of cooked sweet corn then slathered with mayo and dusted with cayenne and parmesan that we used to buy from wheeled street carts for lunch in Chicago. I'm sure all that steaming corn and mayo stored together was a risk, but a delicious one.
Terrie- I think anything sufficiently sweet can take a teeny dash of heat to cut through and balance it so it's not cloying. And with some much spicier cuisines, like Thai, they often serve sweeter German wines as accompaniment because they can cut through and compliment the heat.
In the quiz, I'm a Daffy-down-dilly!
Clare2e,
Yeah, I hadn't considered a one word title followed by dot com. Those could be all taken by place holder folks. The more conventional titles with words run together are still open like "ABridgeRunsThroughIt.com" I'm sure.
Well, if the other book sells well, just take the title back and sell more books that way.
Come to think of it, I'm switching my title to "Jaws."
Oh Alex, sorry for my confusion. I thought you were suggesting a literal "....com" name. I already had reserved the available related domain.
If you're taking Jaws, I guess I'll have to take TaleOfTwoCities.com. I'll get lots of high-schoolers looking for help with their essays.
Post a Comment